Friday, November 6, 2026

Stay Alive , Berlin 1939 to 1945, by Ian Buruma 2026 342pg

 


1/1/26 The six years of war living in Germany and Berlin under the Nazis.

The writer's father was forced to work in Berlin at a factory that made brakes and machine guns between spring 1943 and a few days before the war ended. He lived in a flea ridden barracks in Rehbruke, near Potsdam, later in Lichtenberg in East Berlin. Meanwhile his parents hometown of Nijmegen was badly bombed. Allied bombing raids went on day and night and at the end was liberated by General Zhukov's Red Army. By then almost nothing was left of the metropolis he had entered. Unlike the writer's mother Leo was not Jewish. People from France , Belgium and Holland, occupied countries, volunteered to work in Germany but most were forced. Students could sign an oath of loyalty to not form resistance against the Nazi's and this delayed labor in Germany. Leo refused and went into hiding. Some men who volunteered to work in Germany had actually joined the resistance. Many simply conformed. How could a filmmaker, actor journalist make a living and remain decent. WH Auden describe the 1930s as the " low dishonest decade "
1935 Leo Borchard once conductor of  the Berlin Philharmonic. He declared politically unreliable and so changed his identity helped Jews was part of the resistance  and returned to conduct the Philharmonic in 1945.
Passport stamped with a J no longer allowed Jews to emigrate legally. Some took a boat from Italy or a train to Siberia to Shanghai. The Kinder transports started after Kristallnacht Dec1938 to Sept 1939 (with later transports continuing out of the Netherlands until May 1940) The originated from Prague , Berlin, Hamburg and Vienna. They arrived in the port of Harwich, England. Up to 10, 000 children from infants till 17 year old's. In England British Jews and Quakers encouraged this and 80% of the children were Jewish.
Bertolt Brecht a communist left Berlin in 1933. So did  Thomas Man who had a Jewish wife. Von Platen was gay like Mann and portrayed as the character in Death in Venice. Toscanini refused to conduct in Germany after 1933. He  told Furtwangler that anyone who conducts in the 3rd Reich is a Nazi, Furtwangler was not a Nazi and did his best to protect Jewish musicians in Berlin and Vienne

1939-----------------------------
1938 Jews were no longer allowed to attend public schools in Germany.
To make Polish aggression more plausible Polish attackers were left on the site but they were in fact concentration camp prisoners dressed as Poles. 1939 1st Sept Hitler declared war on Poland.
 William Shirer was Berlin correspondent for CBS radio hired by Ed Murrow and there from1937 till 1940 Dec.  Records of jazz including Benny Goodman and Louis Armstrong were still widely available and popular. Coca-Cola was available till war was declared on the US. Anti Nazi pastor Martin Niemoller, his Paulus Church still stands in Zehlendorf today. He was arrested in 1938 for resisting Nazi persecution of Jews. He was released in 1945 and lived till 1984. Sachsenhausen Prison was for Jews or political unreliable and had criminals who had special privilege's to terrorize others prisoners.
The UFO Studio produced 1930 The Blue Angle with Marlen Dietrich and 1931 M   with Peter Lorre the Jewish actor who left to the US in 1934. Jud Suss the anti-Semitic film was a success but after that people preferred sweet or romantic operettas. They desperately tried to attract Marlene back to Germany as she went to Hollywood. Income tax increased and ration coupons  were introduced.
Listening to foreign radio was forbidden even before the war with Poland and the public was warned that foreign radios was a part of the war to demoralize the German public. However there was a demand for earphones to quietly listen.  From 1937 Air raid drills were practiced. Windows had to be blacked out and cars headlights and petrol station no longer sold petrol to civilians and on driving licenses were given to cars in the war effort. Public transport was limited and there was a run on bicycle stores. Many car accidents at night due to the darkness. The dark Berlin offered opportunities for prostitutes'. Plenty of wine and champagnes looted from France While German beer was rationed.  Half the Jewish population who lived in Berlin in 1933 had left by 1939
Before Kristalnacht there were still 65 Jewish papers and 30 Jewish publishing houses in Germany. Now the Judisches Nachrichenblatt was under Gestapo control. Kosher butchering was banned. A Mischlinge could serve in the army.
 The poet Jochen Klepper and his Jewish wife committed suicide in 1942 and in 1992 a stamp was printed of him in Germany.

1940-----------------------------
In the winter the water supply was cut off to apartments to stop pipes bursting and you were only allowed  to bath Saturdays and Sundays, and you saw people carrying small amounts of coal that they managed to get hold of. Frozen rivers meant hardly any fish available. Fruit and vegetables were in short supply and potatoes was limited to a kilo a week per person. 
Friedrich Schiller's William Tel annoyed Hitler as it glorified a Swiss rebel that killed a tyrant.
Many accepted the lesser evil of the Nazis to defend our country against the Bolsheviks.  women were encouraged to become bus conductors since there were no men and to work as nurses. Wunschkonzert  1940 and Die grosse Liebe 1942 starred Friedel Shuster great successful musicals   but barely mentioned Hitler. and the Nazi party.
The jazz musician Coco Schuman offered a musical escape route "A person with swing can't march in step" Anglo American jazz number were passing German titles in music sheets sold. Goebbels knew how much German troops liked jazz, the British also knew this and BBC  broadcast jazz.
The film studios were like a sheltered haven from Hitler, Heinz Ruhmann  , Werner Krauss Ferdinand Marian all had Jewish wives. Max Reinhardt left Berlin for Vienne in 1933 and the went to Hollywood in 1937 and died in 1943.
The Nazi anti-Semitic movie Der ewige Jude  was screened in 1940 and was a commercial flop but was used to educate SS troops. Jud Suss was a success even in France also the movie The Rothschilds but the German audience had little appetite for such propaganda so Goebbels went for distraction rather.
For a woman to survive in Berlin it helped  to be young, healthy and attractive. There was still hope by Hitler that Britain and France would capitulate. April, German troops invaded Norway to save Scandinavia from British influence. Denmark was a major producer of ham, butter and eggs for the occupation troops and to plunder for the folk.
April 10th , 4 days after Rotterdam was struck by the Luftwaffe obliterating the centre of the city the Dutch capitulated marking the end of the Phony War or Zitzkrieg. Hitler's excuse for going into a neutral country was to counter a similar move by the British.
 On July 18th was the last big celebration of victory by German troops that paraded through the Brandenburg Gates. The first time this was when Prussian troops were victorious over France in 1871.
In summer the Luftwaffe attacked airfields and industrial targets, that did not have the desired effect so to break British morale the started killing London  civilians. This resulted in a major RAF attack in September 26th. Berliners were stunned as Goering assured them could not happen. So Berlins population now became anxious. The times of cinema opening were brought forward and schools started later. Goering thought this would strengthen German hate of he British. Good-night in Berlin became Bombenlose Nacht. Food was plentiful that summer through the occupation of Denmark and Holland. Germans could live very well on potatoes cabbage and bread. One could not ignore the growing number of death notices in the press.
Musicians in Berlin as well as factory workers were called up to the military. The Nazis hated Niggermusik. Musicians from occupied countries were drafted to entertain Berliners. They played American Jazz but disguised them  with German titles. Polish workers were distinguishable by a big P on the coats and were considered inferior peoples and were forbidden to have relationships with the locals. Polish workers and POWs were put to construct large air -raid bunkers. Albert Speer was Hitler's favorite architect. 
Children were now evacuated and taken to Nazi education places in the rural areas. Parents were not allowed to visit them to interfere with their education.

1941----------------------------
Hitler had conceived of the idea of the world capital Germania and the first building of it in Berlin had been completed by architect Albert Speer.
Erich Kastner author of Emil and the Detectives works were amongst the burned books of 1933, he was neither a resister or a Nazi. Smoking on public transport was forbidden as was sale of tobacco to women under 25.
How much did people know as letters sent home from the front concealed more than they revealed and letters from home did not want the men to know about the air raids. "Tommy coming over for a visit" Transgression against the ban on foreign radio stations were still wide spread in the Wehrmacht.
Hitler deputy Rudolf Hess took off for Scotland in  a 2 seater Messerschmitt to have an audience with King George VI  who he thought was surely sympathetic to the German cause. He remained in jail after that. Goebbels put out that he had become insane.
In June there rumor's of invading the USSR and the public talked about following Napoleons failure. We see the anxiety of the German people who were easy to believe anything and that the Russians would welcome them as liberators, and Russia would collapse from within. It was difficult to disguise the toll of the war with death notices in the press of men fallen. Meanwhile in Berlin people were in packed bars and restaurants. The enthusiasm for the Nazi's and the war in Berlin was not as wide as Goebbels claimed.
April, Jews must wear distinctive badges, while factory owners needed Jewish labour. Many Germans who passed people with the star bowed their heads, partly out of shame  and to spare Jews of the humiliation.
August. Protest  by Graf von Galen: The Roman Catholic Bishop of Münster against the gassing of about 70,000 disable, and mentally ill under the Nazis. This killing was stopped. 
Will you commit suicide or allow them to deport you? Joachim Gottschalk a leading film actor had a Jewish wife and son, minutes before the Gestapo arrived he opened the gas in his home and they 3 died. 
A German patriot von Moltke was worried about the moral price of the killing as the blood guilt cannot be atoned in our lifetime.. Berlin had a love affair with American culture. Bertolt Brecht or  George Grosz were obsessed with the vitality of urban jazz age America which the Nazi's called degenerate Negro and Jewish culture.
Goebbels considered Romeo and Juliet 1936 as fine but it completely escaped him that Leslie Howard was a Jew born Steiner. Segregation in the US was an inspiration the Nazi lawyers.
Charles Lindbergh and Henry Ford were a boon to Nazi propaganda and Goebbels said he had proof that Roosevelt was a Jew.  

1942-------------------------------
Letters home from Russia spoke of frostbite and amputated limbs. the press showed Russia bodies littered around but never German bodies. The public were called to donate warm socks books fleeces blankets to keep the troops warm. 
In Berlin people were freezing and sometimes alleviated by packages from soldiers in occupied France. Foreign diplomats were supplied with extra rations on Hitlers orders so that they would write favorable reports on Germany. Food taken from occupied countries helped Germany even if the locals starved. If anyone has to go hungry it shall not be the German people.
Jews now had to hand in their dogs, cats that either went to animal welfare or were killed.
Konrad von Kardorff was a successful portrait painter trained by Max Lieberman one of the great German impressionists. Max had died in 1935 but his widow Martha committed suicide just before she was taken to Theresienstadt. 
15% of women  arrested in Berlin were infected with venereal disease many of them syphilis. Goebbels was worried about the sexual habits of foreign workers.
Winter of 1941 and 1942 British bomber left Berlin but razed Lubeck, Rostock, Cologne , Easen and Bremen.
Germany claimed she was fighting a just war against savage Judeo Bolsheviks. Art in the National gallery showed that Berlin would surpass Vienna as the worlds cultural capital. Stephen Spender who had lived in Berlin in the early 30s called the center meretriciously dazzling, and seemed strained and false. Speer wanted German movies to emulate and surpass the glamor of Hollywood. The Great Berlin art exhibition of 1942 was so mediocre that even Goebbels found it a bore.
Rote Kapella or Red Orchestra consisted of about  500 men and women who helped Jewish fugitives and spread anti Nazi pamphlet. Another resister was Herber Baum a Jew an activist in the Young Communist League, 25 members of this group were arrested plus 29 others plus another 150 Jews picked up and random and executed. Hitler demanded that the remaining Berlin Jews be deported. It took longer to round up the Rote Kapella who kept up printing pamphlets.
Wilhelm Furtwanger was asked to conduct the Berlin Philharmonic to celebrate Hitlers birthday. High culture and popular entertainment was still thriving in Paris. Jean Paul Satre published books.  Edith Piaf sang her chansons. Django Reinhardt 1910 to 1953 who was of Romani descent continued to play his guitar. As long as there were no Jews critical of the German they  used this to seduce the French who considered it an act of defiance.
1942,  16 transports of 1000 Jews  each left Berlin for the killing fields in Poland under Governor Hans Frank.
Runkfunkverbrecher (radio criminals) It is not known how many Berliners listened to the forbidden enemy. Many understood that anyone fighting for Hitler is working for Germany's ruin.  There were over 3 million foreign workers in Germany.  Many were French POWs Men and women from Poland, Ukraine Russia and other parts of the Soviet Union called Ostarbeiters. 
The triumphalism of the earlier years was fading and endurance and perseverance were demanded. For Christmas stores were told to stay open longer to avoid queues.

1943  -----------------------------
Total war was more an act of desperation than a triumph even though Goering proclaimed in a New year speech it would  a year of victory but no success without sacrifice. Bombs were falling and so the authorities had no chance time to go knocking on doors to round up Jews. "Christmas trees" would fall these were by the pathfinders to illuminate a place to bomb. Bombs alone never broke morale.  
Jan. German 6th Army with Paulus surrendered in Stalingrad. German public were warned that the Russians would thirst for revenge against the Germans. Teenages were taken out of school to man anti-aircraft batteries. Albert Speer agreed to release the Jewish workers from armament factories to deport them as Hitler wanted a Jew free Berlin. Some Jewish workers were warned by colleagues to get away. Many started committing suicide.
1943 March Roughly 1,700 to 2,000 Jewish men in "mixed marriages" with non-Jewish ("Aryan") women, who were detained. This Rosenstraße Protest resulted in Goebbels releasing the husbands and children.as it was bad for the morale on the home front.  More than 6000 mischlings survived as a result. In 2003 this legend was used in the movie Rosenstrasse.
Now the worry was the barbaric Russians and what they would do to the Germans. The annual commemoration of the fallen hero worship call Heldengedenktag felt more like a funeral with Hitler looking subdued and older than his 54 years. Schools were closed so that teenager could man the anti-aircraft batteries. Women up to 40years old were mobilized to work in factories. Bars beauty parlors and luxurious restaurants were closed. 
The miraculous heroism of Baron Munchausen travel gave its name to a mental disorder in which people have fake symptoms of imaginary illness. This became an expensive lavish movie as a war distraction to show Nazi Germany could outdo Hollywood. The script was written by Erich Kastner and that  made it successful even though he had written Anti Nazi fiction and was banned and so Kastner had to choose a pseudonym. He however put in subtle images that were not detected. When Hitler was told who wrote it he ordered that Kastner must no write another line.
People who gave shelter to Jews were now worried that dead bodies of Jews could be found in bombed out apartments. A bounty was paid of 300 Reichsmarks to give away a Jew.
Nearly 2 and a half million non Jewish  foreign worker died of starvation in German in the last 3 years of the war.
Ostarbeider with a distinctive  O on their coats were kept as slave workers. When many of these died of starvation the death certificate said heart failure. Dutch Belgians , French and Italian could walk around town in their own clothes and visit cafes.  With the prospect of defeat people did not like the presents of so many foreigners.
The writer father Leo Baruma worked in a factory that made brakes for trains and a light machine gun. Because he also spoke French and  German could act a a translator for workers. He was able to go to the Berlin Philharmonic, soccer matches and movies. In the end Leo married a Jewish women 7 years later, his mother.
Hamburg was bombed into a firestorm that obliterated 60% of all houses and depleted the oxygen so that many died. Goebbels now in a panic ordered the evacuation of all children from Berlin. However freight trains with terrorized Jews were still leaving Berlin. 
1943, Sept  Langbehn traveled to Switzerland and met with Allen Dulles (the precursor to the CIA) to feel out Allied terms for ending the war. He had sounded out Himmler after 1944 Wolfs Lair assassination' failed Himmler quickly had him hung. 
Oct. Bomber Harris decided to obliterate Berlin. The 19C Romanesque Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church was a burning torch. The Berlin Zoo many  animals died or escaped.
Hotel Eden  where young Billy Wilder once worked as a paid dancer for lonely women was now a ruin, but there were still queues outside of cinemas.
People were no longer  wanted to celebrate  Christmas under the conditions. The authors father never liked bangs and  firework celebration as a result of these times.
1944 -------------------------
People were being buried alive by bombings and there were badly burned bodies, air mines were bursting peoples lungs. Unter der Linden was badly bombed.. One could easily drown in the underground shelter where water pipes burst and flooded. American Flying Fortresses bombed by day and RAF Lancaster by night. Unlucky people in prison cells died in the raids. More than 400 thousand Hungarian Jews were being sent to Auschwitz.
Most diarist remark how little anger was expressed against the Allied bombers. Though making their lives miserable Brits were Germanic peoples. 
The public had heard from soldiers of the  German atrocities against  Ukraine , Lithuania, Poland and other places and killing Jews. The Nazi's now had enemies on both sides. Soon it will be our turn.
Sign were put up for Hitler's birthday "Belief in the Fuhrer is belief in victory"
June 6th the Germans knew of the Normandy landings. "Defeatism" became a capital crime. "Children enjoy the war for peace will be terrible" Soviet vengeance was coming.
Actors to avoid being conscripted wanted the filming a a movie to last a long time, however many were no longer alive at the end of the war. 
There were several attempt on Hitler's life 3 times in 1943 and 2 in 1944.  Then
 1944 July 20, (Operation Valkyrie / Wolf's Lair): Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg planted a briefcase containing plastic explosives under a conference table. Hitler claimed that world Jewry had plotted. .2 Fieldmarshals and 19 Generals as well as a total of 5000 other suspects were executed. There was a show trial to humiliate the suspects.
1944 , Sept Volkssturm  Males between 16 to 60 who were not in the regular army, to protect Belin.  Later women ad girls were recruited.  They wore black partly uniforms and own clothes as well as an armband over 175,000 were killed.

1945----------------------
Again Actors with Heinze Ruhman 1902 -1994 jumped on the chance to make a movie and avoid having to fight. Hitler's birthday was no longer an occasion for flag waving rallies, nobody now hung out Nazi flags and the Russian armillary could be heard. The punishment became harsher to keep the population in line. The Grab Detachment of SS men and military police in search of defeatist and deserters. These were called Keterhunde as the were hung  chained by their necks to lampposts. People could not look up and the many lampposts in berlin.
The Peoples Court was bombed with the hanging judge Roland Friesler underneath he died in a direct hit from a US plane. People were crowding onto trains without windows to move westwards.
Wilhelm Furtwanger waited out the Third Reich in a nursing home in Switzerland.
Coming from Pomerania, Silesia and East Prussia , even old ladies and young children weren't spared by drunken Red Soldiers. 2 million people remained in Berlin when half a million Soviet troops with 6000 tanks began to attack. With the end near Nazis were keen to do a good deed even SS officers letting Jews or political prisoner go for a bribe.
Civilians were still scared to hang a while cloth outside. The one prison commander refused to carry out the execution on prisoners for his own survival. 2 hours later they were free.
The civilian population were all in bunker as was Hitler and the Radio broadcast that Hitler was in Berlin and by miracle would save the country! Ha Ha. There were still SS men partying with their girlfriends in special underground shelter.
At the Lazarett military hospital Nurses put a red cross on a white sheet with lipstick hoping Soviet soldiers would leave them alone, it did not.  There were so many suicides many who shot themselves or cut their wrists were Nazi officials. People were shoving through tunnels, and anyone who fell was trampled to death. Burst pipes caused the U-Bahn to floods with rats trying to escape the filthy water. While Berlin was a sea of flames. Whenever a horse was hit by gunfire citizens rushed out of shelters to cut warm flesh off and consume in the bunkers.
The Russians faced 40,000 Wehrmacht and about 40,000 Volksturm helped by Hitler Youths (called "caseroles" a mixture of old meat and green vegetables.) Armed with only Panzerfausts anti tank hand held weapon. Women and Girls were also forced to fight. In Berlin more than 100,000 civilians died in less than a month. Propaganda stories still promised miracles and that General  Walther Wenck was coming to  rescue Berlin. Wench knew that this was doomed and instead he opened a corridor over the Elba saving up to 250,000 soldiers and civilians  to surrender to the Americans.
Berlin even saw camels trudging in streets perhaps they were brought from Turkestan. The Russians often did not have proper boots to wear.
Georgy Zhukov told his men to remember their families who had been torture and to take brutal revenge. Jewish officers tended to be kinder to German civilians. The first thing that the Russian soldiers said was Uhr  (watch) which they never had in remote parts of the Soviets. They were also sent to look for guns, which could mean hiding Nazi's.   The ability to speak Russian often made a difference between life and death.
Rape is a thing done by most conquering armies but the violence against German women was  extraordinary. Hospital estimated  100,000 Berlin women were raped and about 10,000 died often killing themselves in shame. Thus part of German propaganda had been based on the truth. One women by allowing the rapist to be her fiancé  secured his protection from further violence.
First Surrender (May 7, 1945): General Alfred Jodl signed the initial unconditional surrender document in Reims, France
Second Surrender Field Marshal Wilhelm Keitel signed May8 VE day  a second surrender. Later at the Nuremburg Trials he was sentence to death and executed.
After the war life was tougher for German civilians so it was said. There were longlines of women paid to clear the rubble, in a landscape of total  destruction

Aftermath ------------------------------
Children enjoy the war, peace will be terrible. Soviet occupiers were better at rebuilding cultural and education institutions along communist lines. Unlike Herbert von Karajan Furtwangler was never a Nazi Party member. Unlike Karl Bohm, director of the Vienna State Opera he didn't glorify the Nazis and protected several Jews from persecution. Furtwangler became principal conductor of The Chicago Symphony Orchestra. 
Of 160,000 Jews in Berlin in 1933 only 1500 were left after the war.
Christmas Day 1989 , Leonard Bernstein conducted Beethoven's 9th by changing "Ode to Joy" to "Ode to Freedom"
We see Stolperstein of stumbling stones bearing names of deported Jews outside the building where they lived.
The city is a monument not only to man's blackest depravity but to its capacity to be reborn and live again.


 

Saturday, October 24, 2026

The Marshall Plan Dawn of the Cold War by Bennen Steil 2018 404pg

24/10/25 

George Washington's greatest act was to leave the presidency so that the US would not develop a monarchy and refused to serve a third term. In his farewell speech September 1796 he urged his countrymen to steer clear of permanent alliances, especially with Europe.  In 1939 less than 3% of American supported entering the European war and there were a series of Neutrality Acts

The US had fought 2  World Wars  that had cost 522 000 lives and on VE day there were 3,077 American troops in Europe, and Roosevelt was determined to return them as soon as possible, and not confront the Kremlin, however the US never returned to isolationism. The President was suspicious of the British Empire as it had once been.
Roosevelt realized that Stalin had not kept the Yalta agreement and that you can't do business with him. Yalta became a synonym for betrayal of freedom and appeasement.  In a meeting with Molotov who complained he had never been talked to that way. Truman said the Carry out your agreements. Truman infuriated Stalin by cutting off Lend Lease. Truman never imagined himself at Potsdam carving up Europe. Into spheres, but the Soviets were bent on sabotaging democracy.. Between America wanting to dismantle the British Empire and Henry Morgenthau Jnr. who  wanted to convert Germany into an agrarian, or agricultural, society.. It would have given Stalin control of a buffer with US indifference.
1947 January Under Truman the State Dept.  gained its full authority in foreign affaires and people like Dean Acheson, George Kennan , Will Clayton and General  Lucius Clay as well as Senator Arthur Vandenberg were in a position to reshape policy. Hiroshima had shaken the world
1945 44 nations had ratified the Bretton Woods agreement but the Soviets were staying out. The Cold War is a tern that George Orwell had coined in 1945. The Statin- Trieste line would mark the border.
1945 12 million ethnic Germans left eastern and southern Europe to return to occupied Germany. 50 million Europeans were homeless. The Nazis had run France with only 15,000 German functionaries and relied on willing French collaborators. The complete social , economic and political collapse was unparalleled in history.   Economic change ranged from Industrial planning in France to nationalization in  Britain and welfare state to seizure of farms and industries in Hungary. European Communist parties were promising a radical alternative to capitalism. The US heartland said bring the boys home and don't be Santa Claus.
1945 August Truman  cancelled the Lend Lease and promised economic reform at home.
British Imperial power came crashing down through lack of gold that was the only acceptable means of international payments. Meanwhile 1947 winter was the worst with blizzards and freezing in most of Europe.
Britain was withdrawing 40,000 troops from Greece, as she not afford it and Washington was asked to step in there as well as support Turkey.    
1947 February Marshals speech at Princeton. He noted that while active fighting had stopped, genuine peace had not yet been achieved.. The way America had just left Europe after WW 1 had not established security.
The first conflict that the US had to deal with Iran where the Soviets were organizing armed separatist is northern Iran. Truman sent the US fleet and Stalin backed down. The Stalin demanded that Ankara accept Russian bases on the Dardanelles. Truman who understood maps told Acheson to inform the Soviet Charge d'affaires of his full support for the Turkish rights to the straits and ordered a flotilla to the Mediterranean, so again Stalin backed away.
British insolvency would lead to the Soviets getting opportunities in 3 continents, leaving a breach of western defenses.
George Kennan had been in posted  to Moscow from 1933- 1937 and again from 1944 to 1946. He said that Russia was implacably hostile to American Interests and Russia expansionists plans had to be contained. Every Communist party in the world was a subservient instrument of Moscow.  A communist  police state was as big a threat as the Nazi one. Congress however felt that the US would be pulling the British chestnuts out of the fire.  
The Truman Doctrine was to protect Democracy everywhere in the world. Turkey had not suffered the war destruction like Greece but it shared a border with the Soviets. Marshal was sent to negotiate in Moscow. Between him and Acheson the concluded that you could not negotiate as solution with Stalin, who never kept any agreement. This was all given in a speech that Truman gave to the House that the US had to bring economic stability and political process to Europe This was a controversial speech and would be blamed later for Mc McCarthyism. . Initially there was resistance to the Truman doctrine on both sides of the isle. 
Marshal was the first 5 Star US General and was formal to the point he said only my wife calls me George. 
The Soviets felt because they had lost the most in the war they were entitled to most reparations. Marshall saw that they never negotiated in good faith and were trying to get the complete breakdown of Europe.

US deputy military governor Lucius Clay banned further reparation deliveries from the American zone. The French wanted to take the heavily industrialized Ruhr region. French Communist would use the specter of German military revival as a fear against Washington and that other countries recovery should be put ahead of Germany. The Soviets wanted to control the whole of Germany. Walter Ulbricht had been groomed by Stalin to take over Germany.
Herbert Hoover following a trip to Europe concluded that the economies of Europe were interlinked to Germanies economy. Despite the heavy bombing 40% of Germanies housing stock remained as did 80% of its industrial plant and machine tool stock. Restraining Germany industrially would also keep Europe in rags.  Marshal understood that Washington had to act alone without Russia, he then gave a radio broadcast on the disagreements between Washington and Moscow.  The economic weakness of states makes them prone to communist takeover. Stalin had no intention of starting a war with the US if he could achieve this by other means. Economic recovery of Europe and Japan would be the central element of Soviet containment and would be cheaper than military readiness. Between 1945 and 1947 the US armed forces had shrunk from 12 million to 1.6 million. Economic aid had never been tries on such an enormous scale.   
Acheson had to shock the public into realizing the economic crises unfolding in Europe  and America's self interest in reversing it. At the same time Henry Wallace's election campaign against Truman was making things harder.  Unless countries could be self supporting there would be no stability in the world.
The instability in France was causing farmers to hoard grains and not supply the cities with food. France and Italy hd strong communist parties.
Kennan and his staff set up a 4 to 5 year program in the form of  outright  grants.  The US must run this show and it was based on the economic federation of Belgium -Netherlands- Luxembourg  Customs Union  This would unify the breadbasket of the east to the industrial center. Helping separate countries would not help and the US had to knock heads together to impose an agreement,    In Germany the US wanted to get the Germans to be self supporting. Stalin could not opt into this plan without giving up his reparation plan, Stalin had to either decline the Marshal plan or enter into an agreement that ended the Iron Curtain.   
Truman kept a distance from this as he said that "anything going on in  bearing my name Capital Hill will quiver a couple time turn belly up and die"    
1947 June 5  Marshall gave a speech on   at Harvard inviting Europe to present Washington with a compelling cooperation request for aid. Initiative must come from Europe. Our doctrine is against hunger poverty and chaos and not against any country. Any government that maneuvers to block recovery of other countries cannot expect our help.  If Moscow rejected the plan it would be the guilty party that divided Europe. Europe themselves had to establish the program of economic  reconstruction for Europe. However the content would be largely dictated by Washington. No mutual European aid, no American aid.
Moscow since the war redirected trade patterns towards the USSR and created a permanent security zone between itself and Germany. Russia said that the Marshall Plan was to ensure American economic domination of Europe, and Molotov obstructed its implementation in Eastern Europe. Molotov could have killed the plan by joining it Averill Harriman later reflected. Russia wanted European chaos not construction, this way these countries could become communist.  
John Maynard Keynes warned of a Financial Dunkirk in 1944 after the cessation on American war aid.   Britain and the US objected to reparation to Russia. 
British policy was to cooperate with all and dominate none. 
Both Poland and Czechoslovakia were keen to join  but Moscow would have not of that. Thus the world Bank halted consideration of a loan to Poland. Czechoslovakia tried to explain to Moscow that 80% of their raw materials came from the West. Jan Masaryk was assassinated by the Soviets
 Marshall realized that US-Soviet relations had  outlived their usefulness during his meeting with Stalin in Moscow.
1947 July,16 European nations including Turkey and the UK in Paris, with the British foreign minister as chairman . The conference set up the European Economic Co-operation CEEC. There would be only 6 weeks to forge a plan. What bound them was the need for dollars. 8 Eastern European states declined to attend under Moscow's instruction. Spain was excluded owing to the bitter opposition to Franco's dictatorship. France was forced to choose between the rise of German production or no plan financed by the US.
Later in 1952 it led to the European Coal and Steel Community and later to the Common Market of 1958. The different currencies would become fully convertible within the union. Italy wanted to be able to export Italians workers as a means of reducing its unemployed and France agreed to allow a limited migration from Italy. Britain had it own imperial arrangement for labor importation as only a quarter of her trade had been with Europe. West European customs Union was an essential step for democracy to resist Sovietization.
The US wanted the German economy to cease to be a burden to the US. This led to the early termination of Denazification and returned more responsibility to the German people. Europeans were compelled to cooperate more and demand less.
Both Italy and France had Communist Parties. Kennan had just released his book The Cold War. de Gaulle was worried about the collapse of  the Franc and the Italians were aware of how much their future depended on the Marshall Plan.

Back home Truman had to convince the Republican that the Marshall plan was the answer to communism. He got help from Republic Senator Vandenburg. 200 congressmen went to tour Europe on a fact finding tour. This major foreign program could be managed without imposing undue hardship on the American people. Republic Henry Stimson pointed out that having won the war at enormous cost the US could not afford to lose the peace and the penalty of delay would increase the size of the job. Think tanks were set up The council on Foreign Affairs and Brooking Institute. The plan was endorsed by 3.2 million American Legion member as well as the World Council of Churches.
The Age of Yalta has come to an end declared the New York Herald Tribune. The US forces had to be mobilized because of Russia's reaction and this was when Eastern Germany was written off. Moscow Radio directed a vitriol stream at the Marshall Plan.
Thomas Dewey the Republican Presidential contender said he would endorse the ERP European Recovery Plan. Before the vote, interim aid was sent to France , Italy and Austria. They were still  worried that France and Italy would go communist anyway.
Truman had taken a tough stand on Russia at the same time the appointment of General Marshall  was seen as above politics and the American people could identify with secretary Marshall. Aid would be cut off if a country came to be dominated by the Communist Party of Russia.
1947 Time Magazine named Marshall Man of the Year. Vandenberg started looking for things that Europe could provide for the US and found rare minerals, cobalt for aircraft engines and uranium for atomic energy. Other Congressmen sought military cooperation. Thus the US had moved far further from isolationism. It was Vandenberg's leadership that  and coordination that got the bill through the Senate. The Marshall plan would be run by the State Dept.
1948 Jan. the Senate passed the bill unanimously. and the first year $5.3 billion was appropriated. and by April implementation began.
The Czechoslovakia's had wanted to join despite Moscow and Masaryk had been pushed out of the window to his death as he had been planning to flee to the West that would embarrass the Russians. 80% of Czech people favored a western style democracy. Finland was forced to remain neutral.
Marshall managed to cajole the French to cooperate with the Germans if they wanted their share of the money also the French feared the Russians.  To join West Germany became a Federal Government. This was a direct threat to the Soviets.   Once the plan was implemented industrialist could start investing money. The Potsdam decisions  were now null and void.  
Stalin was now trying to push back and the threat was military, and  the    US were keen on securing bases the deal with this. 
Half the aid goods had to be sent on US ships    Both Spain and Ireland were excluded Spain as it was under a dictator and Ireland as they had been neutral and not invaded.                                             
The plan  would beat Communism be economic, rather than military means and take Western Europe off the US dole.1948 April the Marshall Plan became law remarkable in the it had only taken 10 months. A communist take over of Italy would have affected the Mediterranean and so the CIA took its covert action her and funded the Christian Democrats against the communist Party. Up to 10 million letters were mailed from the United States to Italy between early 1948 and the April election there to tell Italian relatives not to vote communist . There would soon be 150 ship with food fuel vehicles and equipment crossing the Atlantic.
1948 June West German changed from the occupation currency that the Russians had inflated. Almost immediately hoarded goods at manufacturer became available in stores. However this resulted in the Berlin blockade of  1948 June to 1949 May. Stalin was worried about the economic affect of the Americans in Germany. This was just after Stalin had expelled Titio's Yugoslavia from Cominform, this showed that the Kremlin could be defied by one of its own minions. The tension in Berlin showed Russian desperation with the success of the ERP.
1949 Tito's Yugoslavia abandoned the Greek Communist insurgents. Stalin blockade was launched as leverage in German. It had not stopped the Deutschmark or progress towards  a West German state or the creation of NATO. And the US in the Cold war demonstrated superior capability of will. West Germany was essential to the ERP.
General Lucius Clay the US army governor of West Germany now returned home he had guided  to a successful conclusion.
August 1949 the first popular election in Germany Ardenauer coalition won, despite Stalin's attempt against it. he would serve 14 years. He was committed to Franco-German reproachment. In East Germany Walter Ulbricht followed Stalin's model. At the same time by 1949 August the Soviets had an atomic bomb. Wally Barbour said about the Kremlin believing that Germany was the key to controlling Bolshevism in Europe. He was the US ambassador to Israel between 1961 to 1973.
Both Poland and Czechoslovakia were sacrificed to the Soviet bloc to strengthen the US long term position. Between 1947 and 1952 when Marshall aid officially ended the industrial output of Marshall countries had increased by 60%. Note these countries production in 1945 was between 34 and 46% of what they had been prewar. Germany and Italy were down to 20%
1953 Marshall received the Nobel Peace Prize.
------------------------------------------------
Lasting Effect.
Mitterrand as his prize for support on German unity secured from Kohl a public commitment on European monetary union. FDRs plans were for an American withdrawal from Europe. NATO through Truman overturned such plans and NATO might expand into the Warsaw Pact territory beginning with East Germany. Gorbechov demanded that a united Germany would be neutral or non aligned, so that   NATOs jurisdiction would not shift eastwards.  The deutschmark was used to force the pace of unification. Gorbechov was already pulling troops out of eastern Europe where some were selling their weapons on the black market. West German money was fueling the resentment of Ruble holding soldiers. Increasing the urgency to repatriate them. Thus the 1947 Marshall plan was serving as a catalyst for wider European integration. Germany would pay Moscow DM 12 billion and give it an interest free loan of DM 3 billion interest free to pay for the removal of its 400,000 troops. Marshall had left the door open to Moscow to participate in the plan, he did so on the basis that  Stalin would slam it shut The Visegrad countries e.g. the Czech Republic , Hungary,  Poland and Slovakia. Madeleine Albright struggled to convey that Russia was a friend against NATO and would protect Europe. The incorporation of Ukraine and adn Belarus in 1922, the Baltic countries in 1940 into the USSR bolster Russia's security while splitting control of Germany created only an equilibrium. The Warsaw Pact  was created in 1955 and  dissolved in 1991. The Russian republics declared independence 4 months later. Gorbochav resigned and the Soviet Union ended. Yelsin warned Clinton that NATOs movement to the Russian border would be a betrayal of the Russian people and did result in a more nationalistic government taking over and a more dangerous Russia. Clinton was committed to seeing Russia moving down the path to democracy.
Yelstin did not want to see Russia's border shrinking more so sent the army into breakaway Chechnya in 1994, then again in 1999 and then resigned in 1999. Days after the expansion of NATO, a bombing campaign started against Serbia
Truman had only added the military element after the Prague coup that showed that governments that could not protect themselves would be subverted by Moscow. Today we see that nothing in Russia's relationship to the west has changed.
Turkey a liberal democracy when it joined NATO in 1952 became less of one under Erdogan's leadership. In 1914 Orban in Hungary declared that "the era of liberal democracies is over"  Georgia and Ukraine Moscow tried to keep the regimes institutionally weak , unpalatable to the west and dependent on Russia.
1997 George Kennan who only died in 2001 aged 101  had written that expanding NATO would be a fateful error of the US policy of the entire post- cold war era and would have an adverse effect on Russian democratic development.
The Marshall Plan is remembered as one of the great achievements of American Foreign policy not merely because it is visionary but because it worked..

How did the GI bill fit into the play for  employment in the US? This stopped the job market being flooded with labor and paid to university and job training  giving a highly educated work force.  This provided $20 a week for  up to 52 weeks for 15 millions of soldiers returning to the job market.  
How did the Marshall plan merge in with American post  war economy?  This acted as a major economic stimulus that absorbed U.S. industrial and agricultural surpluses, prevented a post-war recession, and built long-term global markets for American goods

Saturday, October 10, 2026

The Things We Never Say' by Elizabeth Strout.2026 207pg

 31/08/26

 A book right up to date of the problems of contemporary USA. Artie Dam, a fifty-something high-school history teacher in a small coastal town near Boston. 

Artie had taught history to 11th graders and had been the assistant soccer coach. In the class when Danny Marino mocked Rhoda Lazarre. Artie stood up and asked the kids " Do you ever feel superior to someone else because you are not. Artie's son Rob had been driving and had an accident killing his girlfriend Heather who had not been wearing a seatbelt and was crushed under the steering wheel. This changed both Rob and his family. Rob had a job in a high tech company that had contracts with the army. He married Francesca a concert pianist who was most of the time in Europe.

Artie had been married to Evie for 34 years, she had married someone from the working class. They had had a quiet wedding . Where as Evie's sister  a few years later had a lavish wedding to a young man  and were divorced 10 years later. His father in law paid off Arties student loans so he now felt like a free man. History tells us that in all, that there has never been a time when people were not killing each other.
Rob came home, he and Francesca were through, he had met someone else. Rachel was a social worker at a hospital in Boston and helped people after they left the  hospital. Rachel wanted children but Francesca did not. A plumber came to fix the faucet and was depressed as his wife was having a affair and his son Danny Marino  knew about it. Danny had written in the first day essay " Every thing in this world is a big stinking lies and people suck.
Artie had been brought up in a basement apartment and his father was the caretaker of 3 buildings. His mother had been crazy and was institutionalized a few times. Artie's sister had not married till she was almost thirty and both their parent had died the year of their marriage. 
Evie had a hard time getting pregnant but they went on a holiday to London where a month later the discovered she was pregnant.. Reginald only married Flossie because she said she was regnant and she wasn't, she was never happy.
Artie took the dingy out to his boat, and lost grip of his sailboat and was being carried down by his heavy boots. A motor boat came and saved him, at hospital it took him time to warm and they checked that he had not had a heart attack. His son Rob asked him if he wanted to kill himself.  At the hospital in the days when one was still able to smoke, Artie had his tonsils out as a kid. The was an oldish woman smoking and her story was that she had cancer and they had to remove half her tongue, she lived alone and she was  scared. Arties father had spoken to her and discovered she had no money and no arrangement for when she left the hospital. She was grateful that he spoke to her while she wept. She is the only one who doesn't hold back the truth.
They saw Francesca playing her heart out on the piano at Carnegie hall. She said she was looking for god when she played ,
Rob and Francesca were going to separate because he could not see the way forward with her never home. Rachel was introduced to them, Evie said she liked  dressing trying to look cool.
Danny Marino was a mess his mother had moved out and back 3 days later. At the soccer game someone had shouted "Jew hater" and there was a fight on the field. A year ago the hostages had been taken in Gaza. 
Ken was the Guy who saved Artie and they met for dinner often as they had a lot in common. Kens had grown up in South Boston and his father was a postman. They had a close friendship and Artie even mentioned that he knew that he hadn't fathered Rob. This friendship was solid despite Kens choice of politics and that Ken was very Catholic.
Artie gave assignments to kids to read letters of Union soldiers to discuss, there was a complaint that Confederate soldiers letters should also be studied.  Hoover Lakeland office had a black and white photo of Martin Luther King giving his Washington speech.  Hoover said to Artie. He (Trump) is going to win "people want authority" he has a cult following. Hoover shot himself in his office. Later it was revealed that he was under investigation by the FBI for harboring illegals immigrants at this home and had received death threats , his mistress had turned him in.
Artie had gone to a Catholic school but not church but the concept of evil never left him. His mother came from an Irish family in S. Boston. She and  sister that was put into an orphanage because of their poverty, after the father died and they received a widows check the girls returned home.  Artie's mother hated the Italian neighbours yet when was always talking to them on the step outside. When mother was in a mental institution Mrs. Ferraro cooked for them.
Students knew little about the holocaust which they should have been taught the year before. He had lied to the students as they could not bring about world peace nobody could.
At the end of summer the boat  get pulled out of the water and wrapped for winter. 
Marie had wanted their fathers genes passed on died with her still born baby.
Elon Musks father was a awful man, and Elon probably had Asperger's.
He understood that Rob had thought about suicide, he was an engineer in a company with government contracts and could not discuss his job. He gets a letter from Reginald Mac Donald  discovers that his mom could not fall pregnant and he had obliged her. He was informed that Reg's DNA was sent for testing and he could have his tested at the same lab. His parents went to London on holiday and after that she fell pregnant and Reg is the father. They had lived a lie together.   Later Evie wanted to take Artie to London and again but he refused  to go.         
Rob has no plans to tell his mother. . Rob did not look like  Reg but had Reg's gait.
Rachel was going home to her parents for Thanksgiving so Francesca was invited home to Robs parents. Rob had been valedictorian of his class and Reg had cheered. Reg had married Flossie because she lied about being pregnant
Is there such a thing as free will Carl Jung is the one to ask? He believed in collective unconscious and coined the words extroversion and introversion.
With the election half the country was stunned and half was jubilant.
Artie realized that he had been mentally removed from his father. His father spoke of how difficult it was to be a German after WW1 and a German veteran of that war. Then came the depression. Artie felt he never learned who had his father been. He learned about sex hearing it through the ceiling.
A women unfaithful to her husband ,her therapist Evie tried to convince her not to tell her husband- honesty comes in different forms. 
Finally Rob realizes that Rachel has issues as she is a kleptomaniac i.e. she is screwed up.  Artie at school late catches Danny writing Fuck --- on the wall. The 2 of them work to erase it and nothing was said. Mr. Dam had ushered him into the world of adults .and changed him. Danny did not want to be like his parents. Kids were worried on how they would pay for their education. Later he told Danny to get his grades as high as possible as he had a chance to get a scholarship. But my father wants me to go into his plumbing business! Does your father love you, then he will understand?
The guy would be in prison if he wasn't bombing the Gazans his corrupt. Artie was aware how much people lied to each other. Few students saw themselves with any prospects in the world. 
He heard that a guy died Charles Schwartz who had a men's clothing store and would go to the homes of his obese customers too embarrassed to come into his store measure them and get them their size clothes delivered.  He was the guy who dealt with Artie when he had a kleptomaniac problem.  Is the Pope catholic ? means yes that is obvious.
Artie " they worst thing I did to my father was that I was not there for him" Rob says he is thinking of writing to Heathers parents. Rob was now out of work with the change of administration.. 
Evelyn Peabody tried to kill herself with Klonopin pills.

----------------Epilogue
Artie watched  as President Trump sneeringly humiliated the leader of Ukraine in the Oval office, and talked of making Gaza "the new French Riviera. He felt his country was committing suicide. Rob came with Francesca and they seemed very much a couple. Rob suggested they go out in the boat, without the cellphone. He told Artie his working for the European Union and it is serious stuff that is why they should use the burner phone. American intelligence can't be trusted any more and are working on their own AI platform. Stay off social media. Rob has a EU Passport. Suddenly a heavy fog came down and they could not see their way back and they panicked but ten minutes later the fog cleared. That was the Winter that Hoover Lakeland shot himself and the new principal was a woman who Artie had misgivings about. Don't say boys and girls as you are not sure of their gender. Students were now using ChatGPT to do their assignments. Students realized that Dam-dam went crazy and had" lost it". Artie missed Rob and Francesca tremendously, then Francesca had a miscarriage and this was hard on Artie.
His friends Carl and Anne retired. Because he loved history the state of the country weighed down on him. Talking to Anne he said "My occupation is gone just like Othello" Rob had been detained for 2 hours at immigration and said he would not risk  coming  back again. Artie died of a heart attack. Danny came to the funeral. Francesca was playing music composed by Artie. Kenneth was talking to the father of Heather Morrison's at the funeral. Evie realized that Artie was a saint and never remarried.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Upward Bound by Woody Brown 2026  183 pg.  4/10/26
Upward bound is an asylum form of  day care centre for autistic children or adults. Jorge a gentle giant and eloper as he would suddenly run off. The narrator's parents refused to accept that he was an idiot because he was speechless., just had to untangle the channels in the brain. His mother worked with him, reading to him children classics and poetry. He also had an aid through middle and high school, he got a high school diploma. The mother became his aid at community college. He became an English Major and dreamed of supporting himself at college by writing a novel. Every morning people would sign the clients in, he could sign but slowly. His father suddenly died of a heart attack. He could not get an actual job as the door was bolted from the inside. When he sees a crime movie he has already figured out who did it 5 minutes after it started. He has many needs and little to  give in return.

At Target Jorge looked for Mr. Potato head. Copacetic vibe -relax no problem. Carlos and Jorge had a connection between them, without language and Jorge gets comfort from Carlos    OCD  patterns, compulsive disorders. Cerebral palsy makes muscles and joints stiff, freezes the face and prevents speech. Tom is in a wheelchair and sometimes is just forgotten.
Echolalia repetitive speech by a child, not voluntary.
College students part timers go home for the summer break, kids who live elsewhere need summer jobs, but feel inadequate in the role.
The school district and Regional Centre had been providing speech therapy , physical therapy, occupational therapy till the age of 18 then it falls away.  They doctor pointed doubt that patients with Spastic quadriparesis have a short life span. He needs someone to read to him a few hours a day.
Mariana had the role of Carlos's mother since she was 11, their mother was a drunk and in jail for robbery.
Ann had a lifeguard certificate so was now their life guard. So extra sessions were added to the pool so that all could get in every day. When poop was seen in the pool they had to get everyone  out. Her first day at Upward bound was a Kafka nightmare surrounded by alien creatures. People who could not walk without lurching, some were silent. This would be good for her resume. The place needed helpers badly. Had she toured the place before agreeing she would have kept walking right out. She should have kept a journal this summer to use as  part of an honours thesis. She felt infected as a person surrounded by zombies. The staff all wore a uniform T-shirt, these people were not retarded they were out of control of their bodies. Ann was thinking  of taking a speech pathology class.
 Carlos is in his mid twenties and has already spent time in jail. 
Getting all 20 into their bathing suits took virtually the whole staff. Autism comes with anxiety, the patients did not like it there and it was boring for them. Emma's mother told her she liked music and she liked it when Ann sang her Beatle songs.  Carlos had no background in disability things.  His sister got him the job after she had been working there a  long time.  The  other staffers were either too young or too stupid to teach Carlos anything. His sister Mariana was the key to survival here she was the best thing at the place. Carlos's mother had chosen drugs and booze over him. His mother had gone to prison when Carlos was 6 and Mariana was 16.  However he still said to Mariana "You are not my mother "when tried to keep him from getting into trouble.
Dave was a Luddite - It is inadvisable to play music as they get overstimulated. He had to deal with insurance and liability. Dave got to be director of Upward Bound without a special ed. or psychology background, and doesn't know about the dominant disability of each client. He depends on Carlos. Dave had come California to work at Hollywood, would love a big Hollywood night with an actress benefactor , but there's no money, he can barely pay salaries. At the show they have girls going round with donation baskets
About a third of the clients live in group homes. The others live at home. 
Walter and Emma like being together; he likes people talking to him as a one sided conversation. They have the same kind of autism and would need trained aids to help this but there are none at Upward bound. They need to point at letters to have a conversation. 
Camp Cammie which is controlled by Upward Bound is for disabled kids and adults. he had his father's bag and he took out of it a pill container a counselor saw that and in a panic grabbed it as none of them were supposed to have medication as this was given to them as needed. Oh my God did you take all of these. If Camp Cammie would not tolerate him who would.
Jorge-   the emergency contact on Jorge's file is the social worker, he is an adult and his family is not responsible for him like a child. Abandonment is part of his make up. Carlos was the only  person who cares about him, and honestly had some affection for him
 2
Avery was a cashier at Target and on a Friday a big tall Latino arrived and gave a shriek. Ten funky people on autopilot and 2 handlers came from Upward Bound like a Magic School bus. The helpers looked young and did not have their cell phones out. Slowly Avery became aware that the group was made up of individuals each different. One was in a wheelchair. This group never buys anything and for her it is the end of her week at 2pm she has a Sociology lecture. The girl aid is a pretty collage student. You earn more as a student in retail. Avery has a stepdad who doesn't like her and wants her out of the house. She sees no future in retail and got a  lot out of psychology class. She can see herself mending broken bodies but not mental problems. Looking on this group she thinks adversity is an incentive for soul building.  Every person struggles with something. Incontinence has got to be a burden.
Jorge ran across the road and a policeman pulled out his revolver and shot at him Carlos had just moved in to comfort Jorge and the bullet went into his abdomen. An ambulance arrived and Mariana went with it also . Carlos died on the way to hospital. The police took Jorge and sent him to a psychiatric hold for 72 hours. The trigger happy cop should have been in the loony bin.  Freaks like Jorge shouldn't be allowed near our homes or parks.
That ended a brief rotten chapter of my life. Carlos was the  best thing about Upward Bound. At the funeral we learn that  Carlos's dad  had left the family and the mother had worked 2 jobs. Carlos had found himself in Jorge , Drew and Emma. Dave took credit for turning Carlos around? Carlos always liked you Walter.
   Walter qualifies for Supplemental Security Income (SSI) with his mother, Lisa, acting as his provider.   Walters' mom decided that she could stop working and take care of him if they moved to a smaller house so they could get by. Walter  started writing a memorial about Carlos, then about Jorge. Walter kept on writing.

 

Tuesday, September 22, 2026

Books by Sabastian Barry who was born in Dublin in 1955.

 A  Long Long Way by Sabastian Barry 2005   292pg

18/09/2026  A story of the  Royal Dublin Fussileers. in the war 1914 to 1918

The book starts with the mother dying of childbirth. The father was Superintendent of Police in Dublin Castle he had been in the force for 40 years. Willie is too short so he can't become a policeman. Willie volunteered as Kitchener requested and joined the Royal Dublin Fussileers., some men joined because they had been given white feathers. They were given a cheering send off by the population as they marched to board at the docks. They were upset by the reports of the Germans mistreating the population of Flanders. Some of the RDF had been based in India and never expected to end up in war.
There were Chinese "coolies" brought to work for the war, ( errors by the author by then they did not have pigtails.) There were Jewish soldiers from Cork and Dublin and the Rabbi  gave them burial rites.   On leave in France the book describes a brothel and a woman with a rash on her leg and a soldier who also got the rash.
1916 On leave in Dublin in Sackville Street outside the Imperial Hotel the police have to deal with an uprising with a baton charge that killed 4 people Many wounded. This upset the morale of the volunteer soldiers who saw this. The rebels had hoped for German help. His friend is so upset by the Dublin riots that he refuses to take orders and is tried and executed by firing squad. The family just get a message,  died in action or died  of wounds. At the trial Willi had not been given permission to speak.
A cloud of yellow smoke was coming towards them and they thought the Germans were using it to hide their invasion, when they realized it was poisonous they began to run. Later on they were equipped with masks but had not been trained for it and there were men who pulled them off and died. The postman would arrive at far away farms with a box containing a few personal effects of a soldier , like an inheritance.  Willi had seen soldiers suffering from shell shock and just sitting and shaking, they were useless to anybody or to themselves and had to be sent home for treatment.
Someone sings the Minstrel boy by based on a poem by Thomas More 1807 became a popular Irish song about a soldier that died at war.

Willie comes home on leave and is given a cold shoulder by his father as he indicates support for Irish independence.  Then he went to visit his girlfriend Greta who had a baby and was married. She had received a message from a soldier that Willie had been friendly with a young whore girl. in France. British soldiers were no longer welcome in Dublin and kids threw stones at him. He visited the Palsey family and they  treated him well. He had admired their son Captain George Palsey. He now had to take a train to Belfast as soldiers were no longer shipping from Dublin. Back at the trenches he was welcomed by his group but the Irish had been replaced by others and he knew few of them and the Irish were considered rebels.
The French had mutanied a year before but the Irish never turned their backs to a fight. The Russian soldiers had refused to fight. He wrote a letter to his father telling him that he loved him and that he was the finest man who had brought up the 4 children without their mother. The priest that had been with him all along was killed and Willie became negligent and was killed in Oct 1918. A letter arrived from his father forgiving him but was returned unopened with his uniform and a few effects.
 Countess Markievicz and Madame Markievicz, was an Irish republican politician, suffragist, socialist and labour activist who was the first woman elected to the Parliament of the United Kingdom.  supported the Sinn Fein. Was involved in the 1916 Easter uprising.
John Redmond (born Sept. 1, 1856, Dublin, Ire.—died March 6, 1918, London, Eng.) was the leader of the Irish Parliamentary Party got a promise that after the war there would be Irish Home Rule. 1914 Home Rule Act was passed in Parliament and with that deal done he called on Irish volunteers to fighting WW1.
Of 200,000 Irish who fought 49,000 died., however some names could have been non-Irish who served in Irish regiments.
WW!  Reverend Adler and 30 Jewish chaplains worked on the Western front.
---------------------------------------------
Previous reading of A long long Way Sebastian Barry 2005 293pp 30/10/20 BC
1896 The book is about William born in Wicklow, Ireland, Named after King William of Orange 1903 Edward VII visited Ireland. 1912 His father was in the Dublin Metropolitan police. After William came Annie then Maud and was 12 his mother died of childbirth of Dolly and they moved into the Dublin Castle. Because William was not 6 foot tall and could not become a policeman he was apprenticed to a builder. James Larkin Irish Labour leader led demonstrations that were suppressed, 4 men killed. He falls in love with Greta when she was 13, her father joined the army to get a job after the riots. A soldier's wife had an allowance to live on. William joined the army because he thought it would please his father if he could not be a policeman he could be a soldier.. A wide range of Irish volunteered evern from the Irish speaking islands of Aran to public school boys. John Redmond encouraged the Irish to volunteer and then after Ireland's good service the British would give them home rule. His brother Willie died in action in the war. while Ulstermen joined to prevent home rule Ava Maria music by Shubbert. Soldiers received rum rationes as well as smoking or chewing tobacco. Tinned maconochie Spam stew) was eaten by soldiers. France had already lost half a million soldiers. Chinese were brought to dig trenches and graves for the dead. Many labourers had left the farms and there were not enough workers. Fields have to be limed because they are so acidic in Ireland. Algerian troops nearby. Germans attacked with gas the birds in front of them went silent.. When a machine gun was used a man had to pour water on to keep it cool. A rabbi also came for 2 Jewish soldiers who died. Irish soldiers were also sent to the Dardanelles. Soldiers going to a whorehouse and suffering afterwards - painful to urinate. When he came home had to be washed by his father to get the lice and nits off him, some had ringworm. 1916 They were about to board a ship in Dublin to return to Flanders and were marched back to the city to deal with the Easter uprising and instructed to build a barricade. "England's difficulty is Ireland's opportunity. Catholics were not given commissions? Gas causing hundreds of dead rats in the trenches. Men joined up to leave bad debts, escape a murder charge, for a wager, lost my way and found it in the barracks, wife in an asylum and wanted to get away. "They don't write books about us only on officers" The next time he got leave they were deloused on the way in England .Some Irish soldiers gave their guns to insurgents. Irish soldiers could not be trusted by the English and they were now unable to conscript Irish so the American arrived in time. On his visit home kids threw stones at him and he returned to England via Belfast. The surviving sergeant major became commander even without a commission as there were no officers to replace him. The US lost 116 thousand troops in WW1 half to flu.320 thousand sick and wounded of 4.7 million who served.
--------------------------------------

The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry2008 301pg 1/3/21
Also the Movie made by Jim Sheridan 2016 Starring Vanessa Redgrave,Rooney Mara, Eric Bana. This story is written and ends in 2007. Rosannes was still institutionalized at age 100. Dr. William Grene, senior psychiatrist at Roscommon Regional Mental Hospital, is like a co-author, he is dealing with serious issues after the death of his wife. He has been working there 30 years and the hospital is to be closed, she was there when he arrived. Personal fates and national fates are incestuausly bound. She had a child out of wedlock whose whereabouts are unknown. Barry’s homage to the holiness of life. No one has a monopoly on truth. The image of Ireland as a forlorn old woman. Out of malice toward Protestants as well as out of a misplaced moral absolutism, Fr. Gaunt has her marriage annulled William B Yates as a child spent his summer holidays in Sligo. Dr Grene asks her the particulars of her admission as the basement archive had been attacked by mice. "I want freedom but it frightens me" What she wouldn't tell Dr. Grene she wrote in notes about herself. Roseanne's father left her Religio Medici, the Hounds of Hell and Leaves of Grass by Walt Whitman. Hundreds from Sligo had fought in the great war. She discovers her father had been in the Royal Irish Constabulary under the British. Her father when rebels came to bury a member he called the priest. Soldiers arrived, got the rebels and shot them. The church was to take no part in the issue so her father lost his job as graveyard keeper and became rat catcher with a Jack Russel dog. This is work you do after dark also because he had hunted down his countrymen like rats. " a living man exiled from the dead" Surplus babies in the orphanage were allowed to die. Before he could kill a rat drenched in paraffin, it escaped, jumped down a chimney and set the orphanage alight, killing 123 girls. A Jewish Mr fine had a shop in the town. She had to leave school on her fathers death to look after her mom. Br. Gaunt says none of the Irish upheaval favour the Protestants. She married Tom and was seen chatting to John Lavelle, a rebel and her marriage was annulled. She met Tom's brother Eaun on a night walk, brought him home and cleaned him up. Belfast was the worst bombed British city after London in WW2. They spend the night together, when she is ready to give birth she goes to Mrs. McNaghty, who rejects her, she gives birth on the beach and wakes up. The baby is gone and an ambulance comes to take her. Having been pregnant "a nymphomaniac "is enough reason to put her into an asylum. She heard the baby was in Nazareth. The inmates were measured for a smock when they came in as a shroud when they left. Dr. Grene came from Southampton, his mother was Irish. His wife died and he looked for solace in Roseanne. Old Irish farm cottages the kitchen sloped to the door as they brought the animal in. There were more women than men in Ireland and wiser women went off to America to be maids instead of becoming old maids in Ireland. There was a period under de Valera 1932 where farmers slaughtered the lambs in the field as there was no market for them, because England put a duty on Irish exports. Queen Maeve is part of Irish myth. Priests felt they owned the country then. the constitution gave the Church power but never made it the established church. Albert Pierpont, an English hangman brought regularly to Ireland to hang dissidents. Tom had gone to Spain to fight for Franco till he understood what that stood for and returned in 2 weeks. Nazareth House is the orphanage in Sligo. Mc Nalty's daughter was a nun in England. John Kane is John Lavelle's son and he is the cleaner at the asylum and is the one who saved the baby. Old Mrs McNulty had been illegitimate herself. Dr. Grene in England finds the baby's birth certificate son of Roseanne Clear and Eneas Mc Nulty adopted by Mrs Grene of Padstow , in Cornwall he goes to see the grave of the nun who was his aunt. Roseane has alway lived on the edge of the known world referring to the beach where she gave birth.

Stay Alive , Berlin 1939 to 1945, by Ian Buruma 2026 342pg

  1/1/26 The six years of war living in Germany and Berlin under the Nazis. The writer's father was forced to work in Berlin at a factor...