Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Sons of Soldiers the untold Story of the Jews who escaped the Nazis and Returned with the US army to fight Hitler by Brian Henderson 382 pages

 This is the Story of the Richie boys   15/10/20

1929 Thomas Mann won the Nobel Prize for literature , he dammed the Munich agreement of 1938.  He lectured to Jewish youth in St. Louis, in German with as translator and said dictators cannot be apeased

1932- 35576 Jews entered the US . Because of the depression relatives in the US could only show that they could sponsor a child not a family.  To get a US visa you had to get a good conduct certificate from the German government this later stopped being a requirement for Jews by immigration.  

Small German  villages you could tell the wealth of a farmer by the size of his manure pile. On Friday the villiage had communal oven was used by Jewish wives to bake halla.
1933 Dachau was the first concentration camp  it was a labour camp with terrible cruelty.   Many governments and Chancellors till Hitler had only lasted a few months.
1933 census Jews were less than half a % of the German population, a half million out of 67 million.
1938 With Kristallnacht Nearly 100 Jews were killed and 30 thousand were arrested.  Many families decided to send away their oldest son.  They sewed a $10 bills into the pants cuff, or took a $75 Leica lens to sell. The Auerbach  Jewish orphanage Berlin had 100 children , many were sent out of Germany. 
Jewish Southern loop  - enter Czeck on route to Holland via Austria, Switzerland  and France.
France, a country of 40 million lost 2 million in WW1.
Poland only lasted a few weeks and had 35 million with 3 million Jews. One Jewish kid was at Kitchener Refugee camp in Kent, had 4000 Jewish refugees  Once Britain declared war refugees stopped arriving. The British army set up a radio receiving station and refugees listened to monitored different German broadcasts
1940 May German invasion of Belgium Holland.. Marshall Phillip Patain was a German puppet and in 1940 started passing anti semitic laws. People fled to the south French port of Marseilles. The US consulate and HAIS  helped Jews get to the US.  Neutral Portuguese ships with extra large flags were used.  
When France capitulated 100 000  French dead and a million and a half French soldiers interned.
At Hyde Park Farm in Virginia Under the guidance of Curt Bondi  30 German youngsters were living, working and learning agriculture, the owner decided to sell the property and their instructor suggested they go into the army. Lynchburg was the only major city in Virginia not captured by the Union Army in the Civil War
1941 All German born citizens were automatically enemy aliens. Some aliens in the army were sent to be non combatants and be in the medical corps.  However  Congress allowed them to be inducted into the army where they were mistrusted. The Pentagon realized that they already had in uniform Jews who knew German culture and over the next 3 years 31 sessions of 8 weeks were held at Camp Richie , Maryland.  An authentic German looking village was built.
Years back the Secretary of War had shut down the cryptanalytic office saying "Gentlemen don't read each other's  letters.
1942 War Powers Act. They had to be in the armed forces at least 3 months. These were fast tracked into US citizenship. Many Americanised their names and made sure their dog tag gave P for protestant and  not H for Hebrew on them.  1935 German born Jewish kids got to the US before the war  1885 became Richie boys.  58 % of all  credible intelligence in Europe was provided by them. After the war they never held reunions and their accents made them unwelcome in veteran clubs. They were told not to reveal their stories. For many this war was their private crusade.
 34 clases went throug Camp Richie with an average of 500 graduates a months. Some interrogated German POW in the North African campaign and new anti tank intelligence helped defeat Rommel.  French, Italian, Spanish, Japanese, Greek, Dutch and others were trained there in a university campus atmosphere.
German   Uniforms captured in North Africa were used. They studied names, dates, ranks and insignia used in every German unit. When  they questioned German soldiers they had to impress them of how much they knew already. As a test someone in German uniform dashed through the class and they had to identify their branch, rank, medals and ribbons and  insignia. They also learned map reading and if they knew German shorthand did advanced courses.
First Army under Orma Bradley. In England they began interrogating German POWs. They also had to plan places in  France where POW camps would be set up. We read about the Normandy invasion and that every unit had some Richie boys.  A few had fled to France and had a French education before getting to the US. In France where the agricultural economy was hardly disturbed there were less French Resistance fighters. 
Spanish slave workers had escaped from the Channels island occupied by the Germans and drew a map of the fortification antiaircraft and machine guns were installed.  German  soldier pay books showed all kinds of information.
Cherbourg surrendered and it included some Americans that were released.  The third Army was under Gerorge Patton who  had fought Pancho Villa in 1914 Mexico. Most newly  captured Germans were infantry frightened and prepared to talk. Intelligence obtained through torture was always suspect.
US soldiers  who came on the liner Queen Mary found it was not escorted as it was faster than submarines.
Brest was a U-boat harbour. Roetgen was the first German city captured by the allies, this was a border town near Aachen.
1944 Dec16th Half a million Germans with 600 tanks dashed to capture Antwerp in a week, through the Losheim Gap under Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt. We get a description of the Battle of the Bulge which attacked US lines through the Ardennes. English speaking German in US uniforms were reported and this made it difficult for Richie boys with foreign accents. 2 Richie boys were captured and executed as Jews by Curt Bruns who later was tried and shot as a war criminal.
Some interrogators worked screening which prisoners would give useful information. A German prisoner who had been in prison as a communist became an interrogator's " trusie"working as a stenographer.
Marlene Dietrich came with the US army to entertain the troops in Algeria, Italy, Britain, France and Belgium. She was taken to see a POW camp from the outside. Germans soldiers recognized her and crowded to the fence to cheer her , despite Nazi propaganda calling her a traitor. 
Hitler's latrine orderly was captured and a humorist published he said that Hitler had shriveled scrotum and this was taken seriously. Wolfsangel - Wolftrap was an early Nazi symbol used a German divison insignia.
Michelin tour guides were picked up along the way for use as maps.
Buchenwald was 5 miles from Weimer which had been the centre of German enlightenment (1650-1800) The press including Edward Murrow documented this.
1945 April 30th Hitler commited suicide. General Gavin was the youngest 2star General in the US Army and took the German capitulation by General Kurt von Tippelskirch.
They met the Russian army in the south on the Czeck German border to avoid a clash. A Yiddish speaker US soldier tried to convince a Jewish Russian soldier to defect to the west but he said if he did that it would endanger his family.
Ravensbruck was the only women's concentration camp and 130000 women had been imprisoned there. A woman internee recognised Ramdohr followed him till she saw US soldiers. A Richie boy understood her and they arrested him, any Gestapo or SS member was considered a war criminal. 
One Richie boy found his cousins had survived the camps another found his mother and 2 brothers hidden in Amsterdam near where he left them.       
 One of these found out his younger brother had got to Palestine and was killed by the British.
V stood for Vergeltungswaffen =weapon of reprisal.  8000 V1s were launched

 

 



 

Thursday, October 15, 2020

The Afrikaners by Hermann Giloumee 2010 725pg

 Afrikaner Narionalism and the failed economics of  Apartheid  17/8/20

 
The expanding frontier gave rise to individualism and then republicanism. The Dutch Reformed Church remained radically exclusive while spreading the gospel. Boer women on the frontier had a powerful position far ahead of those in England and each child inherited an equal part of the estate strengthening the position of women. Literary rates were low The indigenous population was not decimated but instead grew strongly.

From the Cape the original indentured servants or their children of the Dutched East India Company moved inland to get away from the company control. Escaped slaves with a mixed race of Hottentots  European, Madagascar and Indonesia and Twana also moved away from control of any authority and formed the Baaster of Namibia as well as the Orlams and Griquas, all spoke Afrikaans.
 Later on the Voortrekkers moved more for economic reasons , but also to get away from the control of any regime.


The Boer War.A tenth of the republican Afrikaners died as a result of the war and more than two-thirds of the stock on farms in the Boer republics was destroyed.
1912 Langenhoven realized that as they speak Afrikaans instead of Dutch they have to write it. As editor of the leading Cape paper set about to write it and he called it a white man's language instead of recognizing its multiracial origin. This was done in the context of middle class Afrikaner and English snobbery.  This was a big mistake as now many Coloured intellectuals have rejected Afrikaans
In the 30s Afrikaners the dominated in farming were becoming urbanized. But less than a third of all white students were Afrikaners and only 3% were professionals, and on average their income was 60% of the English speakers
1932 South Africa went off the gold standard and for the next 40 years we saw growth of 5% p.a.  The war years solved the poor white problem and blacks  started moving slowly into jobs previously held by whites. 
You had integrated slums but in slum clearing and settled blacks into black townships.

 The Broederbond was founded in 1918 with the memory of the defeat in the Boer War. That 27 000 Boer women and children had died it British camps and the Anglicization policy. Many of the early leaders were Calvinist church leaders, it became a secret society providing many Prime Ministers and government  influence. All Nationalist PMs or leaders except de Klerk.
WW2     Smuts took the country into the war with a majority of 13 in parliament.  Cape Coloured had the vote entrenched from  the Act of SA Union and voted for white representatives.
 
Many Afrikaners did not support fighting for Britain and felt that in the same way as the 1902 Treaty of Vereeniging that ended the Boer War was unfair so the Versailles treaty had caused WW2. The SA Army was all volunteers and 50% of them were Afrikaans speakers  as it offered an opportunity as they had few skills.
They Greyshirts in SA who supported the Nazi's were the equivalent of the Hitlers Brownshirts.  The Ossevabrandwag or OB started in 1938 and had a mass membership.
Afrikaner Nationalism first wanted to get rid of the British so by 1961 it became a Republic. They lived in a world of their own and did not take any cognisesence of the black population.
After WW2 SA was positioned exceptionally well developed  for high economic  growth, natural resources sophisticated  financial system, good trade connections, well run civil service despite having bad non white education. 

In 1938 Afrikaners controlled 84% of Agriculture but very little of the rest of trade and industry 60% of Afrianers worked in Agriculture by 1975 most of them worked in cities and besides their control of agriculture had a good share of the rest.
1948 Liberals pushed for the extension of Qualified vote for blacks this would have made a Middle Class black society that would have had a vested interest in Capitalism. Instead Colored and some blacks in the Cape who had constitutional Laws protecting their qualified vote were removed from the voters role in 1953 they had been Smuts supporters.

Capitalism is a free market " lasses fare", but secure property rights, open trade, free labour markets
Apartheid minimized the competition of the lower paid. Here you legally mandated what different groups could do in the economy. making it very inefficient system.  White workers were against both black workers and bosses. This minimized competition against the lower paid blacks, this was also central business planning with a number of government companies. A vibrant economy depends on upward mobility.
 
  
The economic obsolescence of apartheid.
The Education System was called Christian National Education
 1953 Verwoed as minister of Native Affairs drew up a school curriculum Bantu education "for the nature and requirement of the black people'' Liberals felt that education  should not prevent the Europeanisation of the natives. This did give all blacks basic literacy 
In the 50s and 60s the economy was based on agriculture and mining with masses of blacks providing cheap labour. Blacks could not bargain for higher wages and there was great economic growth. The government invested very little in black areas.
After WW2 South Africa had exceptionally high economic growth, abundant natural resources, good foreign exchange earnings, sophisticated financial system, a good technological base, and good trading in the world's system.  Stability was what kept investment going.  South American shows the populist demands that stunted economic growth.
The examples of the 50s and 60s Kenya and later Tanzania and Zambia who experimented with socialism with disastrous consequences , reenforced  the Apartheid theory amongst Afrikaners.
Because little funding went to black education and there were curbs on training of blacks and coloreds and the poorest had to travel furthest to work because of the group areas acts.  Future growth depended on black skills.
Hendrick Vervoed always believed that confronted with the choice of being rich and integrated  or poor and segregated that the Afrikaners would choose the latter. 

It failed to build up an export manufacturing section and was dependent on cheap black labour and  gold export. In the 50s and 60 most of Africa became independent except for those on S. Africa's borders

1966 the Heyday of Apartheid under Verwoerd  it took till 10 years after his death to realize the disastrous direction he had set the economy. All housing in African townships had been frozen. By the end of the 60s 1 to 1and a half million extra blacks  should have been urbanized  No economic plan was made for decentralization. Verwoerd had such a persuasive personality that even intellectuals were swayed by him, he was assassinated before he sketched the end of the apartheid road.  But growth was despite apartheid but it never reached it growth potential, however he did not intend to adjust apartheid to the economic demands. Stability was also kept as Black wages were rising relatively better than white wages. High economic growth should have adjusted apartheid.
 A Broederbond survey  of Afrikaner's asked if they should allocate more land above the 13% to the struggling homeland and the members said no.  
It suited white farmers to have lots of cheap labour  so did not want them to move to the cities. 
In 1938 Afrikaans speakers controlled 87% of agriculture and a fraction of all other sectors. By 1975 they controlled 82% of agriculture and roughly 20% of each other's sector finance mining etc. To join the civil service you had to know both languages well and not as many English speakers had a full command of Afrikaans.  Military spending remained low until the 1980s

Most ANC leaders were either in jail or in exile
The Bantustan Policy , black homelands were set up each with their own civil service that offered channels for black advancement without threatening the Government.
In Kwa Zulu  Butaletzi was against independence for the Zulu people which was 20% of the black population. Butalezi was not puppet and backed regional integration of KwaZulu Natal. He was the only leader who could stand up to the ANC.
By the 70s the homeland policy showed it was economically unviable, the majority of the Bantustan people depended on remittances from families in cities. It was a way to reduce the number of black SA citizens. Funds going to these reserves were classified as foreign aid.

1973 the white unions started giving permission for blacks to be skilled workers and job reservation was now slowly lifted but it was too late.

There was a decline in the price of gold and other commodity exports at the same time in 1973 a soar in energy prices.  The policy of import substitution had been exhausted by the 1970 and because labour was kept out of cities industry began to mechanize. Black wages started going up which took away the competitive edge. The poor whites of the 1930s that were helped by the Apartheid system were now retiring and trained blacks were not available to take their places.

By the mid 1970s social spending was causing a crisis and there was a war against Angola.  By the 1980 the taxes paid by middle class whites trebled. By the end of the1970s  the realization of economically viable homelands had failed. They tried now to incorporate the Colored and Indians into representative government 
The ANC Freedom Charter had called for nationalization of strategic sectors.
Few township residents owned property.
Alan Paton had warned that the Afrikaners could hold onto power by a military dictatorship or by Afrikaans intellectuals from with in the community changing things, not the English  liberals influences.
TV was kept out of SA as long as possible amongst other things  to protect the Afrikaans language.
The Broederbond tied a large section of the Afrikaner community together including academics, professionals business elites.
 1976 to 1978 The Nationalist had a leadership crises, most Afrikaners were religious and the church still offered no critics of Apartheid. 
TV began showing blacks hatred for the system and that the younger generation of blacks were more disaffected than their parents .
1978 2 books on the Broederbond were published  and  listed the 13,262 members. It was no longer a secret organization. They had failed to keep stability and were they just feathering their own nest?. In the 1980s the more conservative members were purged and the cabinet turned to other organizations for advice.

By the 1980s few township blacks owned property so did not pay rates, so local authorities had scarce sources of cash, the biggest source was the beer hall but they had been destroyed in 1976. Residents stopped paying rent, water and electricity.
                                     --------------------------
August 1985 2 weeks before PW Botha was meant to give his Rubicon speech. A policy meeting was held and Pik Botha was given permission to go to Europe and explain the changes to come but PW never gave the speech as we now know he had a stroke.
Between 1910 and 1929 Cape Coloured had the vote , this was guaranteed in the Union Constitution even though they could only vote for whites. It was their vote that kept Smuts in power and their representatives that voted to go to war against Germany. It was interesting that in 1994 they voted for the Nationalist Party who disenfranchised them earlier..
1943 during the war the word Apartheid  was first used  in Die Burger that it was the Afrikaner viewpoint. There is a similarity  between the  Afrikaner nationalism and the German one which was Nazi'ism.
All that is left of the old Afrikaner nationalism is Orania a town in the Northern Cape on the Orange river with 1000  while residents  it came about through a legal loophole.



 The Afrikaners became an expert civil service  which was enormously lost after 1994.

The Afrikaners were latecomers to the cities where the English monopolized the economy. After the Boer War English became the sole medium of  instruction in the country.  In the Cape the intellectuals  and elite were moving over to English as a medium Afrikaners could no longer read Dutch 
 Two seemingly irreconcilable goals: on the one hand there was the black demand for freedom and justice and on the other hand there was the Afrikaners’ quest for ethnic survival,
1976 S. Africa was the 18th largest economy in the world.

--------------------------------
The ANC initially was influenced by Mahatma Gandhi who developed his political outlook in SA
By 2004 more than half of Afrikaans schools were forced to switch to duel medium instruction.

Afrikaans share of the economy 
                                                 1938           1954                1975
Agriculture                               87%               84%                  82%
Mining                                      1                   1                       18
Manufacture, construction        3                   6                       15
Trade  commerce                      8                   26                      16
Finance                                     5                   10                      25
By 1970 they were 80% of all  white civil servants.
1960  Blacks 10.92        Coloureds 1.50       Whites 3.08  (19.6%)    Asian 0.77 million  Total  16 million
2011              41.00                           4.61                  4.68  (8.9%)           1.28                         51.77 million

2011 Afrikaans mother  tongue speakers 40% are white ,50% Coloured, 9%black ,1%Indian
2014 Afrikaans speakers Whites 2.7 million = 60%  Of the Coloured 3.4 million = 75%
Between 1976 and 1994 for 18 years the GDP averaged at only 1.65% resulting in a drop of 25% of real income that affected the poorest.

  

A History of Modern Britain by Andrew Marr 2008 602 pgs.

   16/4/24 This book is a social History of Britain from the end of the WW2 till the book was written. .  I only made notes on the period en...