Monday, August 9, 2021

Frozen Hell: The Russo- Finnish War of 1939-40 by William R. Trotter 2000 270pg

 The Winter War 9/8/21

Between the Gulf of Finland and Lake Ladogo lies the Karelian Isthmus.

1703 May Peter the Great selected the swampy, bug infested Delta to build a new Capital St. Petersburg.

More than 100,000 died during the 10 years to build this city and now a quarter million Russians and 25,000 Fins died because Leningrad was so close to the Finish border.

1809 Finland was under Swedish suzerainty  till then. Military service was a favorite rout of young Finns in the Tsarist army. Finland as a part of the Russian Empire 1809–1917. Nicholas II in 1894  appointed Bobikov as Governor of Finland and after that Finns could be conscripted unwillingly. 

Sibelius’s Finlandia roused nationalist fever and in 1904 Bobikov was assassinated on the steps of the Senate in Helsinki.

1915-1916 Finns got professional military training in Germany.

1917 Finish parliament assumed responsibility for their affairs and Lenin who lacked troops recognized Finnish neutrality. With German help the Reds in Finland surrendered  and the 1920 treaty of Tartu a state of peace was formally recognized between the USSR and Finland. 

The White Finnish Government had allowed both Russian Whites and the British Navy to attack Bolshevik on the Finnish coast.  In the Petsamo region the Finns gave the British Empire consortium a nickel mining concession.  Both the Soviets and Germany supported Scandinavian neutrality

1931 Finland’s various Communist parties were outlawed, and by 1932 Finland’s flirtation with fascism was over.

The Finns felt Stalin's demands were a start for further appeasement.  General Mannenheim tried to make the politician see the truth. Stalin wanted land as a buffer zone. Such a concession would surrender the Mannerheim line making Finland more vulnerable to attack.  Leningrad was the cultural heart of the communist state and revolution as well as a major industrial center.

1939 Nov 26 First shots fired.

Gustav Mannenheim was a Swedish aristocrat in Finland and went to the Finnish corp of Cadets, but was expelled from the corps for AWOL so he crossed the border to the Tsars Cavalry School and became a lieutenant in 1989. He fought in the Russo- Japanese war. Later was sent on a 9000 expedition to collect information on the topography of the southern border and in that time he went to Lhasa and met the Dalia Lama.

He fought in WW1 and hurt his leg and was in Odessa to recovery while the unit he was in was wiped out.

He returned to Finland when the Bolsheviks took over in Russia. He was “The Bloody Baron" against Red supporters  in Finland  80,thousand  were rounded up and put in a concentration camp. 10 thousand died in 6 months and 8 thousand were executed by firing squad as part of the White Terror. His defeat of the Bolsheviks got him an Iron Cross from Kaiser Wilhelm II.

1920 he set up the Mannenheim Child Welfare and became chairman of Finnish Red Cross. 

1931 became chairman of the Finnish Defense council and in 1939 when he said they should give in to Stalin’s demands was asked to retire but the war started before he stepped down and appointed commander in chief.

He was born Swedish speaking was fluent in Russian and French, could converse in English , Polish, German but only started learning Finnish at the age of 50.

The Finnish campaign was an embarrassment to the Russian officer class and 50 years later there is very little of it written in Russian print. Russia planned to solve the war in 12 days; she had the equipment to have her own version of a blitzkrieg. In the Red army using individual unitive could lead to going to a gulag, and fighting was overseen by inexperienced party ideologues. Into some of the densest forest without accurate maps with heavy useless amour and their tanks were not painted to suit the environment. Merekovs troops had to clear out the Finns in 2 weeks before the subarctic winter could ruin the timetable

The Finns were made up of troops from local areas similar to what they knew from childhood. 

Mannenheim set ups his headquarters in Mikkeli (St.Michael) from where he had run the war against the Reds.

The Finns had a defense Navy of 13 thousand men but Turku harbor was icebound at this time.

O W Kuusman was to be Stalin puppet government to be head of Finland and he signed a treaty giving Stalin every concession he asked for.

Tanks attacked without infantry and got stuck on the defense rocks, and brave Finns could attack bombs to the soft underbellies or attack them with. The Finns supply of guns and weapons were limited and they had to use all sparingly. Thousands of civilians of the Karelian isthmus had to be evacuated and their homes destroyed so as not to provide the enemy with shelters. Buoyance charges were set to blow up the ice below the tanks, which began to avoid the lakes which is what the Finns wanted. The Finns laid large stretches of cellophane on the lakes so they looked unfrozen. From the border to the Mannenheim line was 12 to 30 km with troops and obstacles set up. 

 

4 days before Christmas was Stalin birthday he was not happy. Long slow trains, windows covered were arriving in Leningrad full of maimed, starving, frostbitten Red Army troops. They swamped the hospitals and the schools were used for the overflow. Voroshilov said "you are the one to blame you killed the best Generals. 3 quarters of the experienced professional leadership had been purged.

Samyon Timoshenko with Georgi Zhukov his chief of staff were appointed to take over. 2,600 medals were awarded to the earlier troops. New tanks were brought in including 43 tons tanks with 76mm guns. Tanks were no allowed to outrun the infantry and massing artillery to fire on concrete blockhouses.  Russian forces could be rotated when fatigued the Finns could not.  The Russians broke through with heavy fighting on 16 Feb 1940

The Finns were hoping to hold out till the spring thaw turning the advance area into quagmire giving them a greater negating position.

 

There were 8 thousand Swedish volunteers and 800 Norwegians and Danes. From fascist Hungary a battalion came. 350 Finnish Americans arrived via a Norwegian port. Sweden wanted to help but her neutrality was very precarious. Fascist Italy gave a lot of moral support

In NY Mayor le Guardia held a "Help Finland" rally. Both Stokowski and Toscanini conducted benefit concerts all of Sibelius music. 

 

From refusing to meet Stalin’s demands Finland paid a high price, they lost the Karelian Isthmus and the Rybachi peninsula. The 105 day war, 24,923 Finns killed and 43557 wounded.  420,000 Finns lost their homes. The entire population at this time was under 4 million.

5000 Russain POW were repatriated and sent to a Gulag by the White Sea, many interrogated and then shot. Russia lost perhaps 270 thousand men and 300 thousand were wounded. The Soviets reviewed the role of political commissars and reduced their authority in battle.

In the Continuation War Finland fought on the side of the Nazis. Thinking that Germany would be the winner and they could regain their lost land. Mannenheim only allowed them to advance to the old border.  Both the Germans and the American believed that Russia would collapse under the Germans in about 90 days, having seen the example of the Red Army ciaos.

1944 Mannenheim Became President of Finland. He died in 1951

Marshal Timoshenko later showed Khrushchev they had detailed maps of the Mannenheim line made before the war by the intelligence dept. but nobody bothered to ask for them. 

 This book is full of details of every battle  fought which I moved over to try understand the historical significance.

----------------

Unfinished Business - The Jews of Finland   article Haaretz October 8th 2010
Finland was a Grand Duchy of the Russian Empire and Jew after 25 years of Russian military service, married and raised their children there
In the Finish Civil War 1918 the Red Guards were defeated. Here the German Imperial Army was involved and defeated the Reds in Helsinki before the main Finish White forces reached there, this was 1) the Civil War. Jews were granted civil equality in 1917and a law of religious freedom came in 1922.
In the 2) Winter War 15 Jews were killed fighting and 1000 civilians died in the bombarded towns.  Hitler saw the contribution of the Finns in the 3) Continuation War as part of Operation Barbarossa.  Between 1941 and 1944 8 Jews died on the battlefield.
After an Armistice with the Soviet in Sept1944 in the north of the country they fought against the Germans  and this is called) the Lapland War.  In total 300 Jews took part in all the wars.
1948, 28 Finnish Jews volunteered to fight in the Israeli army machal and most returned to Finland afterwards. Today in Finland the Jewish community is about 1000 souls. 
400 thousand Finnish- Karelians had to flee when the area was occupied by Russia that is about 10% of the population.
During the war Finland handed over 2000 Russian POWs to the Germans about 60 Jews amongst them.  Had Germany won the war the Finnish Jews would have ended up like other European Jewry.
Many Helsinki Jews were Swedish speaking. There were never Jewish workers in Finland and never radical left of anti- Zionist Jews like in Poland.

1971 Max Jacobson was Finland Ambassador to the UN.  In 1939 his father Jonas Jakobson invited Jabotinsky who visited  Finland.

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

A History of Modern Britain by Andrew Marr 2008 602 pgs.

   16/4/24 This book is a social History of Britain from the end of the WW2 till the book was written. .  I only made notes on the period en...